May the words of my mouth and the meditations of all our
hearts be always acceptable in your sight oh God, our strength
and our redeemer.
I imagine them there in the temple- Jesus and a great
crowd that has come to listen to him. Jesus has been teaching
here since his impressive arrival in Jerusalem, just about a
week previously. The temple is the center, the very heart of
Israel’s life – even more, the
heart of its worship. It is an imposing structure, although
still under construction. This temple, the third temple, was
started by Herod, in 20 before the Common Era. As Luke tells
us, it has beautiful stones. More than one commentator,
describing the temple, quoted the words of the first century
writer Josephus; he said: “Now the outward face of the temple
wanted nothing that was likely to surprise either men’s minds
or their eyes, for it was covered all over with plates of gold
of great weight, and at the first rising of the sun, it
reflected back a very fiery splendor and made those who forced
themselves to look upon it to turn their eyes away, just as
they would have done at the sun’s own rays.”
An impressive building, indeed, but even more, the
place where the presence of the holy was felt and experienced
and believed to dwell. All this wonder and beauty was offered
for God’s glory, and yes, as is so often the case in such
situations, certainly for the glory of the builder, the
benefactor. The temple was also the setting of conflict
between Jesus and the religious authorities of his day. When
he came first to the temple, he took a whip to those who were
selling things in it; he drove them out, saying, “It is
written: my house shall be a house of prayer for all people,
but you have made it a den of thieves.”
He has been teaching there every day since, and Luke
tells us that from that time on the leaders kept looking for a
way to kill him, but they could not find one because all the
people were spellbound by what they heard. It is in this
place, in this moment then, with the listeners marveling at
the grandeur of the temple, even as they are spellbound by
Jesus’ words, that Jesus prophesies destruction and
devastation. “The days will come,” he says, “when not one
stone will be left on another, and all will be thrown down.”
Just for a moment, feel into that astonishing word, and
even more, feel into the loss that it implies. Jesus is
talking about the violent destruction of a peoples’ very
center, what they have counted on spiritually, communally. He
is talking about the loss of the locus of meaning, the
destruction of the space of the divine presence, the place
where they, where we, have given our best and where worship is
possible.
Perhaps you have had some experience like this. I think
myself of our experience here at Holy Apostles of the
devastating fire – can it really be 17 years ago? That feeling
of standing out on 9th Avenue, seeing the smoke and the ruin,
and wondering what would become of us as a people. The answer
came, of course, over time, but we had to go through the
devastation.
We in New York also have the experience, more secular
but perhaps even greater in its symbolic power, of the
destruction of the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001.
Surely all the questions of what will become of us, of what it
means, of how we are to live on the other side of it, are
echoed in this passage. We may have had less dramatic and
public experiences that nevertheless have this quality of the
loss of center. I think for myself of going home to the place
where I grew up and finding the woods in which I wandered
every day of my childhood were simply no longer there.
I think of experiences of life falling apart, center
not holding, the end of the world as we have known it. The end
of a relationship perhaps, or the end of a job, or the coming
of a sudden catastrophic-feeling diagnosis. One example of
this that has been the most poignant for me happened to my
downstairs neighbor just about ten years ago, when her husband
and son were killed by a bus crossing the street. Surely in
that instant life was shattered. It would never be again what
she had known.
Jesus prophesies the destruction of the temple as the
harbinger of yet a larger destruction, and then the
consummation of all things – the very end of the world, and
the dawn of a new age. His own ministry has been the sign of
this new realm of God breaking in, and his death and
resurrection are the pivot point on which it all turns. And of
course the immediate response of his hearers is “When?” and
“How shall this happen?” The first Christians, like many
Christians after them, were preoccupied with the notion of the
end of time. They expected it to come quickly, in their
lifetime, and that expectation was not fulfilled. Their
expectations were part of a larger worldview, part of a
literary genre that was common in Jesus’ day, an
apocalyptic worldview. The worldview is that crisis and
destruction are being brought by God’s majestic intervention
from outside of history, making everything new, vindicating
the faithful and righting wrongs, and it speaks specifically
to a suffering and persecuted church.
By Luke’s time, however, by the time that Luke is
telling this story to his community, the temple has already
been destroyed. So, there’s a kind of a backwards and forwards
in the way I believe we’re meant to hear this passage. The
delay in the end of all things is already being experienced by
Luke’s community. There’s already a sense that we have to
understand the end and the consummation and the action of God
in a somewhat different way. There is still a real crisis:
life, as those early Christians knew it, had been shattered
and remade and it would be shattered again many times, as it
has been for so much of human history. The instability, the
wars, the insurrections, the floods and earthquakes and
famines and plagues that Jesus speaks about have come and are
coming.
But this sense of many different perspectives on time
helps me as I look at our times, our times with so much
violence and so much war – our time of terrible threats to
human life and to the earth itself. It helps me to wonder, to
pray, and to see these crises not as an end coming from the
outside of history, but as a challenge to my imagination and
faith, to my sense of responsibility as a human being and a
person of faith, to my discernment about how I am called – we
are called – to participate in the birth pangs of the new
thing that God is doing.
The actual meaning of the word “apocalypse” is
uncovering, or revealing. It is to see what has been hidden or
what has been denied. That new revelation may explode suddenly
or it may emerge gradually in the midst of profound
disorientation. The neighbor that I spoke of, who lost her son
and husband, said to me, “I had no idea that I was signing up
for an advanced course in mystery.”
What do we see in these moments of crisis? Surely we
see, if we are open, something about ourselves, about our need
to change – perhaps about guilt and responsibility, perhaps
about our longing for God. If we are faithful, hopefully also
we see the love that undergirds us and the interconnection
that we have with all things. But even more, the revelation,
the apocalypse, is to say that God is present – not in the old
expected way, not limited by our prior experience of God, but
present in truth and power and mystery, in hiddenness and in
sudden flaring forth doing something that we can only begin,
dimly, to imagine.
It is this uncovering that is beginning to happen
throughout the rest of the passage, as Jesus’ words about what
is coming for his hearers, and especially for his followers,
move from social devastation to personal participation. “Don’t
pay attention,” he says, “to those who come with easy answers
and explanations. Don’t go following after them.” And then he
says, “Don’t be terrified!”
Clearly there are plenty of reasons, in such a moment,
to be terrified. And it’s comforting to me, if strange, that
Jesus doesn’t just say, “Don’t be afraid,” in the way that
happens often throughout scripture. Terror can be an expected
response to the confrontation with the powers that be, to
persecution, to betrayal by loved ones, to imminent loss, and
yes, possible death.
But still Jesus says, “Don’t be terrified. Find your
courage.” Courage. Strength of heart. The first virtue, as
Bill Coffin said, that makes all others possible. “In this
apocalypse, this crisis, this catastrophe,” Jesus says, “you
will have the opportunity to testify, to bear witness.” That
word-witness- yes, is martyr. “Some of you will be killed, and
all of you will be hated because of my name, but not a hair of
your head will perish.” Some of you will be killed! But not a
hair on your head will perish.
These are hard and sobering and difficult words, and
yet we have to hear them. We have to ask, “What is the
opportunity that Jesus speaks of in moments of crisis?” He
says it is to gain your soul, to grow, to become your soul, to
gain a sense of what is truly essential, to find that
undergirding love – that trusting connection to Jesus – that
vast and open heart. It is to find that opportunity to
participate in what God is doing in ways that we cannot yet
predict and cannot control.
So several questions are raised for me by this passage,
by these difficult and bracing and sobering words. How do we
grow in courage? How do we live in difficult times?
Surely it is a process. I think, of all the Biblical
characters who show us this, perhaps Peter is the most
powerful in his absolute failure and cowardice at the time of
Jesus’ crucifixion - his repentance, his working through, his
forgiveness and his going on to be a powerful witness to the
resurrection.
We talked a lot on this year’s retreat about how we
grow in courage. I shared with those who were there that one
of my own mantras comes from Eleanor Roosevelt, who said,
“Every day do something that scares you.” It’s like there’s a
working of the muscle, of taking risks, of stepping up. I know
that when I am afraid, I have to lean into the community. I
have to find my time in nature, which for me, helps me connect
with something larger than myself.
In thinking about how to grow in courage, I first began
to write about different prayer practices, breathing and
meditation, that help me. But honestly, the most important
thing is to remember to pray at all, in whatever way you pray.
It may include screaming and weeping and stretching your
heart. Surely it involves starting to move, taking the first
right step. That is, in fact, where I connect with that other
strange word of Jesus in this passage, who says, “Don’t
rehearse what you are to say. I myself will give you words and
wisdom.”
I think it’s true that we don’t discover how we can
serve, how we can live, how we can be brave, by waiting and
thinking about it. We find it in the moving, in the action, in
the doing, in the commitment.
And then the other question is: what is the witness
that I am, that we are called to make? Each of us will have
our own answer to this question in the context of the
catastrophes and challenges of our time and of our personal
lives, and in the context of our faith – our baptism, our
commitment to a God of wild and radical love who we are called
to serve before the idols that claim us, that call us, that
seduce us…the idols of security and money and status and
power.
I know that our witness often looks like compassion,
like hospitality. I know that it includes standing up for the
dignity of every human being, particularly those who are
outcast and marginal, that it looks like claiming and
committing to the integrity of creation. I know that our
witness involves the costly work of forgiveness and
reconciliation, the discovery that my enemy is part of me, one
whom I must learn how to love. That witness may be made in an
open hearted “Yes” or an equally open hearted “No”, with
clarity, setting boundaries. It involves vulnerability; it
insists that community is more important than things and it
depends in gratitude and trust on the wild and radical love of
God, the one who is present in surprising and mysterious ways.
Whatever it is, Jesus tells us that we will have the
opportunity in this crucible of destruction and courage to
gain our souls. So in the end, I invite you to muse on and
live these questions:
What is it in your life and in our world that is
ending?
What frightens you? How can you hear the words of
Jesus: “Don’t be terrified?”
What is being revealed? Where is God doing a new and
startling thing? What are the glimmers or bursts of
revelation?
We are coming towards the season of Advent with its
message, stay awake and watch. What do you need to live in
apocalyptic times?
What will help you grow your soul and keep your
courage?
And finally, what is calling out now for your witness?
What is the testimony that is yours to make?
Amen.